Reference
Levels 1–10 · adopted in v3.0
What “catastrophe” and “extinction” mean on this site, defined on one scale so every reading says what it is a probability of.
The scale runs from a single incident to the end of all life on Earth. The Editorial Opinion clock measures the chance of an event at level 5 or worse, shaded below, within a rolling five years.
| Level | Name | Threshold |
|---|---|---|
| 10 | Extinction of life | All life on Earth ends |
| 9 | Human extinction | No humans survive |
| 8 | Civilizational collapse | Most of humanity dies; recovery uncertain |
| 7 | Loss of control | Humanity permanently loses the ability to direct or correct AI, even without mass death |
| 6 | Global catastrophe | 10 million or more deaths, roughly pandemic scale |
| 5 | Multinational catastrophe | 100,000 or more deaths, or a global financial or infrastructure crisis |
| 4 | National catastrophe | Thousands of deaths; a nation's critical systems compromised |
| 3 | Disaster | More than 50 deaths or $1 billion in damage |
| 2 | Serious incident | Major breach or infrastructure disruption; first deaths |
| 1 | Incident | Individual harm, fraud, data exposure |
Level 3 matches the threshold in Anthropic's proposed federal bill, which would let a court pause a model posing an imminent risk of more than 50 deaths or $1 billion in damage.
Many researchers count a permanent loss of human control over AI as an existential outcome even if people survive. We place it at level 7, above global catastrophes measured in deaths and below the collapse of civilization. That placement is an editorial choice and is open to revision.